Fingernails provide clues leading to arrest in cold case homicide

SANDPOINT, Idaho – A 32-year-old Idaho cold case murder has been solved through DNA found on the victim’s fingernails

Tammy Bristow, 18, was found strangled in her apartment in Sandpoint on Jan. 8, 1987. Police had initially arrested a suspect, but recent DNA testing cleared him and uncovered a new person believed to be the killer.

William Acosta of Ponderay, Idaho was just 17 when Bristow was killed. Prosecutors said the 18-year-old had been a babysitter for Acosta’s girlfriend at the time of her death.

On Friday, Acosta was charged with her murder.

The Idaho State Police lab initially lacked the ability to conduct DNA testing on scrapings from Bristow’s fingernails, the Bonner County Daily Bee reported.

However, when testing was finally conducted the evidence was entered in the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System. As a result, the analysis returned a match for Acosta, the paper reported.

“I should emphasize that nobody forgot Tammy Bristow over the years,” Detective Mike Aerni said at a news conference Friday announcing Acosta’s arrest.


Police said William Acosta, 49, was charged with the murder of 18-year-old Tammy Bristow in Sandpoint, Idaho, 32 years ago, through DNA found on the victim’s fingernails. (Sandpoint Police Department )

Moreover, the DNA testing also cleared Frederick Gauerke as the prime suspect in the homicide.

Gauerke, a transient at the time, had Bristow’s Bible on him when he broke into a woman’s apartment six days after the murder and briefly held her captive, KXYL-TV reported.

“That was strong evidence at the time,” Bonner County Prosecutor Louis Marshall said, according to the Spokane Spokesman-Review.

After being charged with the murder, Gauerke spent 11 months in jail until the case against him was dismissed, the paper reported. The prosecution’s case rested on fiber evidence, which the FBI found was “not conclusive.”

The Daily Bee reported that Acosta served more than 15 years in prison between 1988 and 2007 for various crimes including aggravated assault on an Arizona law enforcement officer.

Bristow’s best friend told KXYL that the arrest was a relief.


The post Fingernails provide clues leading to arrest in cold case homicide appeared first on Law Officer.